Chapter 10: The left intellectuals and the incomplete revolution: Ideological debates over South African history
- Hans Erik Stolten(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | Chapter 10: The left intellectuals and the incomplete revolution: Ideological debates over South African history |
|---|---|
| Contributor | Hans Erik Stolten(author) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2025.BK478.10 |
| Landing page | https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/478 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Elize S van Eeden. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral rights of the editors and authors have been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Published on | 2026-01-27 |
| Long abstract | This chapter seeks to reveal how left-wing social scientists tried to change the apartheid system and the post-apartheid reality. It demonstrates the importance of history for politics, public opinion and progressive agency. During apartheid, South African intellectuals actively contributed to create an accumulated, collective memory, useful for the country’s oppressed majority. Progressive history writers’ reconstructions of prior resistance struggles were one of many preconditions for the broad resistance against apartheid. In the years leading up to the regime change, a majority of black South Africans probably had revolutionary expectations. Nevertheless, the new South Africa moved in a neoliberal direction. The revolutionaries won but were unable to use their victory for the scenario they had imagined. What role did left-leaning social and historical thinking of the time play in raising hopes that proved to be unrealistic? This contribution uncovers ideological positions in disputes between social scientists to explore the origins and course of important South African historical debates, and it attempts to clarify to what extent paradigms have been shown to be converging, incompatible or simply irrelevant. The independent, intellectual Marxism, used as an inspiring corrective to realpolitik and tactical organisational thinking, has become a scarce commodity. However, the scholarly world are not ‘beyond’ the debate over socialist alternatives to liberalism. This debate reflects some of the most fundamental societal divisions. In this chapter it will be argued that history has not ended; that the 1970s and 1980s Marxist discussions have a persistent, progressive significance; and that the historic left-right debate between radical and liberal forces has continued relevance. The question, if South African history writing was actually liberated with the fall of apartheid, seems more relevant than ever in the light of the left radical discussions during late apartheid. |
| Print length | 23 pages |
| Language | English (Original) |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| BISAC |
|
| Keywords |
|
| Funding |
Contributors
Hans Erik Stolten
(author)Hans Erik Stolten is a Danish historian who worked as a researcher and lecturer at the Centre of African Studies, University of Copenhagen, for several years. He has written articles, reviews and reports on South African matters for several periodicals and was the editor of two books on the anti-apartheid movement. Stolten worked as a research fellow at the Nordic Africa Institute in Uppsala, Sweden, for several years and was later affiliated with the Centre for the Study of Equality and Multiculturalism at the University of Copenhagen. He also worked at the Danish State Archives. He now conducts most of his work at the consulting firm Jakobsgaard Research and the Danish non-governmental organisation (NGO) Global Aktion. Stolten is the editor of* History Making and Present Day Politics: The Meaning of Collective Memory in South Africa* (Nordic Africa Institute, 2007).
