Export Metadata
| Title | Chapter 11: On decolonising South African historiography |
|---|---|
| Contributor | Thula Simpson(author) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2025.BK478.11 |
| Landing page | https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/478 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Elize S van Eeden. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral rights of the editors and authors have been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Published on | 2026-01-27 |
| Long abstract | Within hours of the Cecil John Rhodes statue being covered in faeces at the University of Cape Town (UCT) on 9 March 2015, the #RhodesMustFall movement was launched to fight for a series of demands that included the decolonisation of ‘Eurocentric’ curricula in South Africa’s university sector. The demands spread nationwide over the following months. Among the many institutional responses was the University of Pretoria’s Curriculum Transformation Framework document of 2016, which distilled the literature on decolonisation into four main demands. One was for greater ‘responsiveness to social context’ (including foregrounding historically marginalised narratives and knowledge); the second required cultivating ‘epistemological diversity’ (entailing the introduction into the curriculum of groups and worldviews from Africa and the Global South); the third called for a ‘renewal of pedagogy and classroom practices’ (requiring overcoming the invisibility of certain groups and fostering inquiry-led learning); and the last sought ‘an institutional culture of openness and critical reflection’ through tackling exclusionary practices within the university. By contrast, the clamour for decolonisation met with a muted response within the historical profession, judging at least from the output of six leading subject-related journals (the African Historical Review, Historia, History in Africa, the Journal of African History, the Journal of Southern African Studies and the South African Historical Journal) in the years immediately following the emergence of the Fallist movement (2016–2021). Although reflections on historiographical themes in the publications covered a wide range, there was little on ‘decolonisation’, even when Historia extended an open-ended invitation to its Editorial Board to ‘weigh in on new directions in the historical discipline'. A couple of publications that appeared during that period offered clues as to the reasons for this lacuna. In his presidential address to the Southern African Historical Society (SAHS) conference held at Rhodes University in 2019, Enocent Msindo noted there was nothing new in the demands for historians of the region to decolonise their practice, for such calls had been forthcoming since the 1960s. Although he argued that the discipline’s response had been inadequate (he claimed, for example, that the curricula of some departments still foregrounded the activities of white people, while others tended to emphasise ‘victimhood’ over ‘agency’ in portraying black Africans), Christopher Saunders offered a more sanguine view in his 2018 contribution to the Oxford Encyclopedia of African Historiography, for he freely acknowledged that South African historians had paid little attention to the question of decolonisation since the end of apartheid, but he attributed this to the fact that ‘South African historical writing had begun to be decolonized long before the political decolonization that occurred from 1990’. Therefore, with some disagreement on the level of success achieved, the two accounts concurred that by 2015, historians of South Africa had been responding to demands for decolonisation for at least a couple of generations. Support for this perspective was indirectly provided by a series of articles published in the history education journal Yesterday & Today between 2016 and 2024. The articles drew attention to various initiatives that were being implemented to decolonise history curricula. But that presupposed the existence of materials suitable for the task, which would corroborate the notion that historians had long since been producing works that adequately addressed the issue. Himal Ramji provided further credence for this conclusion in a 2018 article where she noted that each successive iteration of the South African school curriculum since 1995 had foregrounded the history of Africa and its peoples. These various observations raise the question of what exactly Fallists would propose historians of South Africa do differently from what they have been doing for the last couple of generations. Jacob Dlamini has repeatedly posed this question, and as he has noted, the answer remains unclear. Having concurred with the observation made by Bill Freund as long ago as 1994 that South African historiography’s dominant liberal and radical traditions shared a ‘master narrative’ of ‘The Struggle’ of black Africans for liberation from white domination, Dlamini argued that South African historiography was caught in a post-apartheid ‘impasse’, because ‘scholarshave been making the argument that if only there were more black historians South African history would be different’, but it has ‘never been clear whatthat difference would be’. He also argued that, viewed within the context of longstanding demands for the ‘decolonisation of education’, the Fallists were distinguished only in having repeated the cry ‘most loudly’. Dlamini added that, if anything, it was time for scholars to consider how the history of South Africa might look ‘if told not as a struggle against apartheid but about something different’. The historiographical pieces as cited earlier indicate that scholars within the discipline have, by and large, turned to thinking about what that ‘something different’ might be. By contrast, Sabelo Ndlovu-Gatsheni, who in 2004 obtained his PhD in history on the 19th to early 20th century Ndebele state, before shifting his focus to decolonial/postcolonial theory, used a 2018 presentation to offer suggestions on how historians of the Global South might respond to calls to infuse their work with decolonial perspectives. He identified three key themes as requiring particular attention: One was the ‘question of power’, which related to how colonialism shapes the contemporary asymmetrical world order; the ‘politics of knowledge formation’, concerning how European epistemic perspectives come to prevail over African ones; and the ‘concept of being’, centred on the ‘racial hierarchisation’ of peoples. In this chapter, I hope to demonstrate that critical contemplation on these themes has been central to the development of South African historiography. But I differ with others who have made this point by contending that the engagement dates even further back than the 1960s. In developing the argument, I will not fixate on the precise term‘ decolonisation’ because the exploration of the two themes underpinning it, namely how to transcend Euro- and white-centric biases in South African history, has proceeded under various labels, highlighting the diverse motives that have guided the respective inquiries. The following excursus into the pre-1990 literature is offered in response to two important post-apartheid developments. The first is the palpable desire among historians of South Africa to ‘move on’ from ‘The Struggle’ as a master narrative. I sympathise with them, yet the fact remains that events since 2015 have demonstrated that decolonial themes continue to inform the questions that non-specialists address to historians. The questions, therefore, cannot be dismissed. This chapter will show that many of the problems and challenges raised by the discipline’s long engagement with those questions remained unresolved. Hence, the questions raised since 2015 hold continued salience and validity, and it is worth re-engaging with them. The second influence relates to the current decolonial literature. For reasons discussed, it has tended to be developed by non-historians, but it has also invariably been presented in abstract, theoretical form. As noted, historians have responded by insisting that the discipline boasts an extensive record of practical engagement with those issues. By revisiting that engagement, the chapter will highlight the practical challenges that have emerged. As one will see, those practical obstacles to decolonisation are frequently overlooked in the more theoretical literature. The chapter will draw out these contrasts to bring the two literatures closer together and in the hope of stimulating more effective decolonial praxis. |
| Print length | 20 pages |
| Language | English (Original) |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| BISAC |
|
| Keywords |
|
| Funding |
Contributors
Thula Simpson
(author)Thula Simpson is an associate professor in the Department of Historical and Heritage Studies at UP, South Africa. Simpson has published extensively on the African National Congress’ (ANC) armed struggle and the broader history of South Africa. Simpson is the author of Umkhonto we Sizwe: The ANC’s Armed Struggle (Penguin, 2016) and History of South Africa: From 1902 to the Present (Oxford University Press, 2021), and he is the editor of The ANC and the Liberation Struggle in South Africa: Essential Writings (Routledge, 2016), History beyond Apartheid: New Approaches in South African Historiography (Manchester University Press, 2023) and The Routledge Companion to Postcolonial African Historiography (Routledge, 2025). Simpson’s work on the history of South Africa has received the Award of the National Institute for the Humanities and Social Sciences for Best Non-Fiction Book (2022) and was also named Book of the Year by Foreign Affairs magazine. Simpson is currently the editor-in-chief of the Journal of African History.
