To live and learn: Notes on alterity and togetherness, or: On living with dogs
- Marianne de Laet(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | To live and learn |
|---|---|
| Subtitle | Notes on alterity and togetherness, or: On living with dogs |
| Contributor | Marianne de Laet(author) |
| Landing page | https://www.matteringpress.org/books/environmental-alterities/read/to-live-and-learn |
| License | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Marianne de Laet |
| Publisher | Mattering Press |
| Publication place | Manchester, UK |
| Published on | 2021-10-06 |
| Long abstract | How to be true to the experience of living together with dogs, when the language that is reserved for human-animal relations insists on describing such relations in terms of domestication, species-alterity and control? In this paper I tell three short stories about my life with dogs, each of which shifts the terms on which such ‘living with’ is possible, as well as the language in which to think of it. The stories give hands and feet to the theoretical musings about domestication, subjectivity, alterity and agency which they intersperse. The first story introduces my canine counterparts Raylan and Kismet in an image; the story is about how this image was crafted and tells of what it produces. Thinking about the othering effect of photos as I try to do a photoshoot of my dogs, I list the work that it takes to be a subject, arguing that the dogs exert agency in this process, so asserting their subjectivity. The second story is about words. I take issue with a line of experimentation in animal science, where MRI scans of dogs’ brains are used to ‘show’ that dogs ‘understand’ or ‘know’ words. Privileging language, which dogs are not supposed to ‘have’, the study on dogs-knowing-words banks on as well as affirms dogs’ alterity. Depending on a protocol in which such alterity is assumed, the study meanwhile fuels the sensibility that dogs are not as alter as they seem. I submit that in their use or non-use of words dogs may not be as alter as the study presumes, nor as non-alter as it suggests; the urge to adjudicate alterity by way of understanding words may be a human preoccupation that has nothing to do with the dogs’ life-worlds. The third story is about the walk. Diffusing the idea that the leash locates power and agency in the human, I relate the intricacies of going for a walk with and without the tether and describe how words, leash, human and dogs together craft fidelity to the practice of being a pack. In these stories, or so I argue, the dogs have agency; it is from doing things together that fidelity – representational, practical, and relational fidelity – to their subjectivity arises. |
| Page range | pp. 185–203 |
| Language | English (Original) |
Contributors
Marianne de Laet
(author)Marianne de Laet is professor of anthropology and STS at Harvey Mudd College in Southern California. Her work on knowledge practices is concerned with the ways in which knowing and sensing together craft the known/sensed object. A psychologically trained anthropologist of science, she is interested in the self as a distributed subject, mediated by the company it keeps with animals and materials. She is currently writing about water and sustainable water technologies; taste and tasting; and living and dying with dogs.
