Planetary alterity, solar cosmopolitics and the Parliament of Planets
- Bronislaw Szerszynski(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | Planetary alterity, solar cosmopolitics and the Parliament of Planets |
|---|---|
| Contributor | Bronislaw Szerszynski(author) |
| Landing page | https://www.matteringpress.org/books/environmental-alterities/read/planetary-alterity-solar-cosmopolitics-and-the-parliament-of-planets-o-bronislaw-szerszynski |
| License | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Bronislaw Szerszynski |
| Publisher | Mattering Press |
| Publication place | Manchester, UK |
| Published on | 2021-10-06 |
| Long abstract | Introduction: how to gain and lose a planet On 18 February 1930, our solar system gained a planet. Clyde Tombaugh, a 24-year-old amateur astronomer and son of a farmer from Illinois, had started work at the Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, Arizona just a month before. The observatory had recruited him to help in the search for a hypothesised planet that had been going on since Percival Lowell had calculated in 1905 that only the existence of a distant, unseen ‘Planet X’ could explain observed perturbations in the orbits of Neptune and Uranus. Tombaugh had been given the task of using a blink comparison technique to detect any differences between pairs of photographic plates taken on different nights of the same area of the night sky (Schindler et al. 2018: 64–68). His successful blinking, by discovering a point of light that had changed position between 23 and 29 January, thus took the complement of planets in the system from eight to nine. But then in 2006 the number of planets in our system fell back down from nine to eight again. The International Astronomical Union finally agreed a new definition of a planet, in an accommodation between competing scientific ‘ways of knowing’ in the astrophysics community – between a ‘structuralist’ focus on what a planet is made of and a ‘dynamicist’ focus on how planets move and interact with other bodies (Messeri 2010:190). The new definition was ‘Aristotelean’ in form, in that it consisted of a list of necessary and sufficient conditions for something to be classed as a planet (ibid.: 191). Thus, the IAU agreed that a planet is a body (i) that is big enough to have made itself spherical through its own gravity (i.e. achieved hydrostatic equilibrium), (ii) that orbits a star, and (iii) that dominates that orbit (Soter 2006, 2007). Pluto passed the first two criteria but failed the third, since it moves in an elliptical orbit that crosses that of Neptune – and is not even the largest body in that region of the solar system. Pluto was thus demoted to the status of a ‘dwarf planet’ or ‘Kuiper Belt object’, a decision that raised much controversy – not least among the wider public, who had got used to the idea of Pluto as part of the complement of planets. What is ‘due process’ in the process of deciding what planets are and how many we have in our solar system? And how might exploring that question help to inform our thinking about alterity in non-human realms? In this chapter I will explore these questions by drawing on the cosmopolitical proposals of Isabelle Stengers and Bruno Latour: proposals for ways to determine what things exist in the world, and how they should coexist, which do not prematurely foreclose or divide questions of fact and value. I will repeatedly return to the two core cosmopolitical questions that Latour poses in Politics of Nature (2004a): how many are we? how shall we live together? I will explore the idea that deciding, reckoning, counting and accommodating might be operations that can be carried out by matter itself. In doing so I will draw a great deal on planetary science, but also on the thought of Henri Bergson, Gilles Deleuze, Felix Guattari and Gilbert Simondon, which will help us develop a geophilosophical understanding of the modes of alterity exhibited by matter under planetary conditions. We will see that the concrete, individual planet that presents to us is a mere effect or phase in a wider ongoing process of ontogenesis, and that the material isolation of planets never wholly sunders them from immanence and possibility. We will also see that each planet exhibits alterity and multiplicity not just in relation to others, but internally, in that planets are always out of step with themselves, which is what enables their becoming. And we will see that the way that planets become, endure and interact involves various modalities of alterity, difference and multiplicity, modalities that are inextricably bound up with planetarity itself: with the particular mode of existence of planets. |
| Page range | pp. 204–226 |
| Language | English (Original) |
Contributors
Bronislaw Szerszynski
(author)Bronislaw Szerszynski is professor of sociology at Lancaster University. His research seeks to situate social life in the longer perspective of human and planetary history, drawing on the social and natural sciences, arts and humanities. He is co-author with Nigel Clark of Planetary Social Thought (2020), author of Nature, Technology and the Sacred (2005), and co-editor of Risk, Environment and Modernity (1996), Re-Ordering Nature (2003), Nature Performed (2003) and Technofutures (2015).
