Trading Justice for Peace? Reframing Reconciliation in TRC Processes in South Africa, Canada and Nordic Countries
- Sigríður Guðmarsdóttir(editor)
- Paulette Regan(editor)
- Demaine Solomons(editor)
- Eugene Baron(author)
- Stanley Henkeman (author)
- Tore Johnsen(author)
- John Klaasen(author)
- Sheryl Lightfoot(author)
- Daniel Lindmark(author)
- David B. MacDonald(author)
- Kjell-Åke Nordquist(author)
- Joanna R. Quinn(author)
- Mikkel N. Sara(author)
- Elizabeth Shaffer(author)
- Lovisa M. Sjöberg(author)
- Line M. Skum(author)
- Christoffel (Christo) H. Thesnaar(author)
- Wilhelm Verwoerd(author)
- Kim Wale(author)
| Title | Trading Justice for Peace? Reframing Reconciliation in TRC Processes in South Africa, Canada and Nordic Countries |
|---|---|
| Contributor | Sigríður Guðmarsdóttir(editor) |
| Paulette Regan(editor) | |
| Demaine Solomons(editor) | |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2021.BK174 |
| Landing page | https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/174 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Sigríður Guðmarsdóttir, Paulette Regan and Demaine Solomons (eds.). Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral right of the authors has been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Publication place | Durbanville, Cape Town, South Africa |
| Published on | 2022-02-28 |
| ISBN | 978-1-77634-209-9 (Paperback) |
| 978-1-77634-211-2 (PDF) | |
| 978-1-77634-210-5 (EPUB) | |
| Long abstract | Conflict in its various manifestations continues to be a defining feature in many places throughout the world. In an attempt to address such conflict, various forms of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) have been introduced to facilitate the transition from social conflict to a new dispensation. The introduction and subsequent proceedings of TRCs in South Africa, Canada and Norway are widely regarded as good examples of this approach. Against this background, a number of researchers from VID Specialized University and the University of the Western Cape had an exploratory meeting in Oslo in 2018 where the possibility for a joint research project under the broad theme of ‘discourses on reconciliation’ was first discussed. This led to two further research symposia in Cape Town and Tromsø in 2019. With the inclusion of specialists working on the Canadian Truth and Reconciliation process, these meetings demonstrated common ground and a shared understanding of the issues at stake. Moreover, it pointed to the differences between the South African, Canadian and Norwegian Commissions. In comparing the South African, Canadian and Norwegian experiences, researchers identified that these countries were, in fact, at different stages of their respective truth and reconciliation processes. This has prompted scholars to revisit and problematise these processes in relation to ongoing societal challenges. In all cases, it is quite apparent that reconciliation between individuals and groups remains a significant challenge. |
| Print length | 338 pages |
| Language | English (Original) |
| Dimensions | 170 x 244 mm | 6.692913385826772" x 9.606299212598426" (Paperback) |
| Media | 2 illustrations |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| Keywords |
|
| Funding |
Contents
- Tore Johnsen
- Paulette Regan
- Kjell-Åke Nordquist
- Stanley Henkeman
- Christoffel (Christo) H. Thesnaar
- David B. MacDonald
- Sheryl Lightfoot
- John Klaasen
- Daniel Lindmark
- Elizabeth Shaffer
- Eugene Baron
- Wilhelm Verwoerd
- Kim Wale
- Joanna R. Quinn
| Landing Page | Full text URL | Platform | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| http://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/174(opens in new tab) | Landing page(opens in new tab) | http://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/174(opens in new tab) | Full text URL(opens in new tab) | Publisher Website |
Contributors
Sigríður Guðmarsdóttir
(editor)Sigríður Guðmarsdóttir is Professor in Practical Theology at Centre for Mission and Global Studies at VID Specialized University, Norway, and Associate Professor in Practical Theology at the University of Iceland. Sigridur started as a co-editor and as a full-time professor at KUN/VID, and the last part of the project has been done as part of her research at the University of Iceland. She specialises in postmodern ecotheology, gender and contextual perspectives to practical theology. Her research interests include postcolonial theory and Indigenous theology. Recent publications include the monograph Tillich and the Abyss: Foundations, Feminist and Theology of Praxis (Palgrave Macmillan, 2016), the chapters ‘Real Presence: Lutheran Eucharistic Practices as an Ecological Resource’, in Religion, Sustainability and Education: Pedagogics, Perspectives and Praxis Towards Ecological Sustainability (2021) and ‘The DissemiNation of Vikings: Postcolonial Contexts and Economic Meltdown’ in Contextual Theology Skills and Practices of Liberating Faith (Routledge, 2020).
Paulette Regan
(editor)Paulette Regan is an independent scholar/practitioner who brings a decolonising critical perspective and applied experience to the theory, ethics, methodology and pedagogical practices of reconciliation and public education dialogue in settler-colonial contexts. Formerly the research director for the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, she was the senior researcher and lead writer on the Reconciliation Volume of the TRC Final Report (2015). Her book, Unsettling the Settler Within: Indian Residential Schools, Truth Telling and Reconciliation in Canada (UBC Press, 2010) was shortlisted for the 2012 Canada Prize by the Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences. Her most recent publications are ‘Reconciliation and Resurgence: Reflections on the TRC Final Report’, in Resurgence and Reconciliation: Indigenous-Settler Relations and Earth Teachings (University of Toronto Press, 2018), (co-authored) ‘Reweaving the Past’, in Memory (Peter Wall Institute, University of British Columbia, 2018) and (co-editor) Pathways of Reconciliation: Indigenous and Settler Approaches to Implementing the TRC’s Calls to Action (University of Manitoba Press, 2020).
Demaine Solomons
(editor)Demaine Solomons is Mandela Rhodes Scholar who teaches Systematic Theology and Social Ethics in the Department of Religion and Theology at the University of the Western Cape in South Africa. His research encompasses the study and content of among other things: black liberation theologies, black consciousness and existentialist philosophies as a means to better engage discourses on reconciliation. He is the recipient of various research awards from the National Research Foundation of South Africa, the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation and the Nagel Institute in the United States. Some of his most recent publications include ‘Overcoming Reconciliation as a Wicked Problem: A Theological Response to the Dominant Split between Heaven and Earth in South Africa’ in Philosophia Reformata (2020), ‘Re-examining a theology of reconciliation: What we learn from the Kairos Document and its pedagogical implications’ in HTS Theological Studies (2020) and ‘The Absurdity of Reconciliation. What we (should) learn from Rustenburg and the implications for South Africa’, in Stellenbosch Theological Journal (2020).
Eugene Baron
(author)Eugene Baron is Senior Lecturer in the Department of Practical and Missional Theology at the University of the Free State in South Africa, specialising in black theologies of Liberation, Reconciliation, Church and Identity. Among his recent publications are ‘Mission studies at South African Higher Education institutions: An ethical and decolonial perspective in the quest to “colour” the discipline’, HTS Theological Studies, 76.1 (2020), (co-authored) ‘The recovery of the prophetic voice of the church. The adoption of a “missional church” imagination’, Verbum et ecclesia 41.1 (2020) and ‘Die Ligdraer as a Grassroots Engagement on URCSA’s Unification and Reconciliation between 1990–1997’, Missionalia 48.1 (2020).
Stanley Henkeman
(author)Stanley Henkeman was the Executive Director of the Institute for Justice and Reconciliation in South Africa. He was a practitioner and the former head of the Building an Inclusive Society Programme at the same institution. Stanley had extensive experience in facilitating learning in various contexts. This includes teaching at both intermediate and advanced levels of the South African educational sector. He was a skilled mediator, public speaker, facilitator and respected social commentator with a long track record of mentoring young emerging leaders.
Tore Johnsen
(author)Tore Johnsen is a Sámi theologian and Associate Professor at VID Specialized University in Norway, specialising in the meaning of reconciliation in the Norwegian TRC process as well as working with capacity building related to the Church of Norway on the matter. Sámi theology, Indigenous theologies, theological decolonisation and reconciliation as public theology are among his key interests. In this context, his academic work is informed by his experience as a Lutheran priest (Church of Norway) in the North Sámi area (1998–2009), General Secretary of the Sámi Church Council (2009–2016) and moderator of the Ecumenical Indigenous Peoples’ Network Reference Group of the World Council of Churches (2015–2018). Among his recent publications are ‘Acknowledged history and renewed relationships: Perspectives on reconciliation work between the Church and the Sami people’, in The Sami and the Church of Sweden: Results from a White Book Project pp. 97–124 (Gidlunds förlag: 2018), ‘How to reconcile Norway with Sápmi? Christ as “reconciler” in a (post-) colonial Norway’, in Witnessing to Christ in a Multi-Religious Context pp. 36–46 (Regnum Books, 2016) and ‘Dialogteologi i etsamisk perspektiv’ [Dialogue theology in a Sami perspective], in Dialogteologi på norsk, pp. 102–119 (Verbum Akademisk, 2016).
John Klaasen
(author)John Klaasen is a visiting professor at VID Specialized University in Oslo. The contribution in this book is presented in his capacity at VID. He is also affiliated with the Department of Religion and Theology at the University of the Western Cape in South Africa. His expertise is in the field of Narrative, Migration, Identity and Church in Christian theology. Among his recent publications are ‘Pastoral care and narrative: Towards a narrative pastoral care approach in intercultural communities’, Luce Verbi/In die Skriflig Volume 52, Issue 2 (2020), ‘Church, narrative, community and identity in times of migration’, Luce Verbi/In die Skriflig Volume 54, Issue 1 (2020) and ‘Narrative and Community development’, Diaconia: Journal for the Study of Christian Social Practice (2019).
Sheryl Lightfoot
(author)Sheryl Lightfoot (Anishinaabe, Lake Superior Band of Ojibwe) is Canada Research Chair in Global Indigenous Rights and Politics and Associate Professor in the departments of Political Science and Indigenous Studies as well as the School of Public Policy and Global Affairs at the University of British Columbia in Canada, specialising in complex questions of Indigenous peoples’ rights and how those rights are being claimed and negotiated in various political spaces. Her recent publications include the chapter ‘Legislative Frameworks for Implementing the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples’, Braiding Legal Orders: Implementing the United Nations Declarationon the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2019), ‘Implementing the UN Declaration: The View from Canada’, in Conversations about Indigenous Rights: The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People in Aotearoa New Zealand (Massey University Press, 2018) and her monograph Global Indigenous Politics: A Subtle Revolution (Routledge, 2016).
Daniel Lindmark
(author)Daniel Lindmark is Professor of Church History and History and Education at Umeå University in Sweden. His research interests include religious reading, popular religion, colonial encounters and historical justice, especially in the northern region. He moderates the network Religious History of the North (REHN). In 2012–2017, Lindmark directed the white paper project on the Church of Sweden and the Sami. His publication list includes (co-editor) The Sami and the Church of Sweden (Gidlunds förlag, 2018), (co-editor) Conservative Religion and Mainstream Culture (Palgrave Macmillan, 2021), and (co-editor) Historical Justice and History Education (Palgrave Macmillan, 2021).
David B. MacDonald
(author)David B. MacDonald is Professor in the Political Science Department at the University of Guelph in Canada. His research focusses on Comparative Indigenous Politics in Canada, Aotearoa New Zealand, Australia and the United States. He also works in the areas of International Relations, American foreign policy, genocide studies and critical race theory. His recent publications include a monograph The Sleeping Giant Awakens: Genocide, Indian Residential Schools, and the Challenge of Conciliation (University of Toronto Press, 2019), (co-edited) Populism and World Politics: Exploring Inter and Transnational Dimensions (Palgrave Macmillan, 2019) and ‘Settler silencing and the killing of Colten Boushie: naturalising colonialism in the trial of Gerald Stanley’, Settler Colonial Studies, 2020.
Kjell-Åke Nordquist
(author)Kjell-Åke Nordquist is Professor of International Relations at University College Stockholm, Sweden, specialising in peacebuilding, mediation and Human Rights. A former Head of the Department of Peace and Conflict Research, Uppsala University (1999–2005), Sweden, Nordquist has combined his social science background with studies of religion and ethics, particularly in relation to the relationship among religion, politics and reconciliation. Nordquist has published Gods and Arms (2013) on the connection between religion and war, An Unlikely Dilemma (2011) on the tension between peace and justice as theoretical concepts and field practice Reconciliation as Politics. A Concept and Its Practice (2017) is based on a multi-year experience as a mediator, analyst and consultant to political reconciliation processes after civil war and authoritarian rule.
Joanna R. Quinn
(author)Joanna R. Quinn is Director of the Centre for Transitional Justice and Post-Conflict Reconstruction and professor of Political Science and at the University of Western Ontario in Canada. She has written widely on the role of acknowledgement, truth commissions and customary justice in Uganda, Canada, Fiji, Haiti and the Solomon Islands. Her recent publications include Thin Sympathy: A Strategy to Thicken Transitional Justice (University of Pennsylvania Press, in press), ‘The Impact of State Abdication on Transitional Justice: When Non-State Actors Fill the Post-Transition Gap’, Peacebuilding, forthcoming, and ‘The Role and Influence of the Diaspora on the Thin Sympathetic Response’, Ethnic and Racial Studies 42.11 (2019).
Mikkel N. Sara
(author)Mikkel N. Sara is Associate Professor in the Department of Social Sciences at Sámi allaskuvla/Sámi University of Applied Sciences in Guovdageaidnu, Norway. His research activities have been mainly in the field of Sámi reindeer husbandry and ecological knowledge related to reindeer herding. Sara has published scientific and popular science articles and books in both Sámi, Scandinavian and English. He has also participated in establishing and building different educational courses and programs at Sámi allaskuvla/Sámi University of Applied Sciences. He makes regular presentations on topics including traditional Sámi knowledge systems, reindeer husbandry and self-government. Some of his recent publications include ‘Ávjovárri – eatnamat, johtimat ja ođđahálddahuslaš rájit’ (Ávjovárri – the land migratory routes and administrative borders), Sámi dieđalaš áigečála 1/2019, Guovdageaidnu, ‘Misreading the Arctic landscape: A political ecology of reindeer, carrying capacities and overstocking in Finnmark, Norway’, Norwegian Journal of Geography (2015), (co-author) ‘Productivity beyond density: a critique of management models for reindeer pastoralism in Norway’, Pastoralism 10.9 (2020).
Elizabeth Shaffer
(author)Elizabeth Shaffer is Assistant Professor at the University of British Columbia (UBC) School of Information and Executive Director, UBC Residential School History and Dialogue Centre. Her current work and research focus on critical enquiry into how information policy, practices and systems emerge and evolve in contemporary digital spaces, with particular attention to social justice issues, impacts of colonialism and collections that document traumatic human events. She is a former director of Collections at the Vancouver Holocaust Education Centre, overseeing initiatives focusing on the digitisation, preservation and pedagogical use of Holocaust survivor testimonies and collections in support of anti-racism education and exhibition curation on issues of genocide. Some of her publications include (co-author) ‘Archiving Collections of Trauma: Identifying Generative Frictions in Canada’s National Research Centre for Truth and Reconciliation’, Archivaria 80 (2015), (co-author) ‘If Not Us, Who? Social Media Policy & the iSchool Classroom’, Journal of Education in Library and Information Science, 55.2 (2014) and ‘Developing an Organisational Information Policy to Mitigate the Risks Posed by Social Media Technologies’, Archives and Manuscripts, 39.2 (2011).
Lovisa M. Sjöberg
(author)Lovisa M. Sjöberg is Associate Professor in the Department of Social Sciences at Sámi allaskuvla/Sámi University of Applied Sciences in Guovdageaidnu, Norway. Her research activities have mainly been connected to religious practices like blessing in Sámi contexts. More specifically, her research is focused on human beings’ relationships with creation as they appear in practices and oral traditions. This includes the study of Christianity in Sápmi from a Sámi point of view. She makes regular presentations on topics including traditional Sámi knowledge systems, Sámi theology and ethics as it appears in Sámi narrative traditions. Some of her recent publications include ‘On God, Gods, and Idols: How to Talk about Sieidi in Sámi ECEC Teacher Education’ Routledge International handbook of the ‘Place of religion in Early Childhood Education and Care’ (inpress) and ‘Kristendomens historia historia på norsk och svensk sida av Sápmi – en översikt’, Teologisk tidskrift vol. 1–2 (2020).
Line M. Skum
(author)Line M. Skum is Assistant Professor in Diaconia at Northern Norway Educational Centre of Practical Theology (KUN) – VID Tromsø, specialising in Indigenous peoples, land-rights and diaconia. Among other things, she is a reindeer-herding Sámi from Senja in the northern Sámi area. Some of her publications include (co-editor) Erkjenne fortid — forme framtid : innspill til kirkelig forsoningsarbeid i Sápmi (Eng. Recognizing the past – shaping the future: input to ecclesiastical reconciliation work in Sápmi) (Orkana Forlag, 2013), ‘Rihpeldihkie jih ektiedimmie gyrhkesjimmie saemien jih daaroen gielesne’. En åpen og inkluderende gudstjeneste på samisk og norsk. (Eng: An open and inclusive service in Sámi and Norwegian) (Kirkerådet, 2006) and Når Moder Jord trues. ‘En studie av hvordan Den episkopale kirke og United Church of Christ tenker og handler frigjørende sammen med Igorot i Mankayan i kampen om land som trues av multinasjonal gruvedrift. (Eng: When Mother Earth is threatened’. A study of how the Episcopal Church and the United Church of Christ think and act liberatingly with Igorot in Mankayan in the struggle for land threatened by multinational mining) (Universitetet i Oslo, 2005).
Christoffel (Christo) H. Thesnaar
(author)Christo H. Thesnaar is Professor of Practical Theology at the Department of Practical Theology and Missiology at Stellenbosch University in South Africa, specialising in themes related to reconciliation such as memory, trauma, justice, healing and restitution. His research interest is transdisciplinary in nature and approaches discourses on reconciliation from this vantage point. He is the chairperson of the Unit for Reconciliation and Justice at the Beyers Naudé Centre for Public Theology at Stellenbosch University. And in further involved in various international research projects on reconciliation. Among his recent publications are (co-editor) Reconciliation, Forgiveness and Violence in Africa (Sun Press, 2020), ‘Alternative and Innovative approaches to reconciliation: A South African perspective’, in Rethinking Peace and Conflict Studies, pp. 125–137 (Springer, 2018) and ‘Intergenerational guilt and shame continue to challenge relations: Some thoughts from the Dialogical Intergenerational Pastoral Process’, in Identities in Flux: Globalisation, trauma and reconciliation, pp 82–98 (Kritika & Kontext, 2018).
Wilhelm Verwoerd
(author)Wilhelm Verwoerd is Senior Research Associate and Facilitator at the Studies in Historical Trauma and Transformation Unit, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Stellenbosch University, South Africa. As a former researcher within the South African TRC and a peace practitioner in (Northern) Ireland, he devoted (re)humanisation/reconciliation in contexts of deep political division. His main research interests include the (incomplete legacy of the) South African TRC, shared historical responsibility of white South Africans for apartheid and colonialism, relational processes to transform (white) resistance to social justice in post-1994 South Africa and embodied spirituality of authentic reconciliation. Many of these interests feature in a recent memoir, Verwoerd: My Journey through Family Betrayals (Tafelberg, 2019).
Kim Wale
(author)Kim Wale is Senior Researcher at Studies in Historical Trauma and Transformation Unit, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Stellenbosch University, South Africa. Her publications include the award-winning book (co-edited) Class in Soweto (Pietermaritzburg: UKZN Press, 2013), a monograph South Africa’s Struggle to Remember: Contested Memories of Squatter Resistance in the Western Cape (New York: Routledge, 2016) and her most recent contribution (co-edited) Post-Conflict Hauntings: Transforming Memories of Historical Trauma (Palgrave Macmillan, 2020).
