- Embracing a Pedagogy of Productive Uncertainty in Higher Education
- Nicholas Strzalkowski(author)
- Sarah Hewitt(author)
- Michelle Yeo(author)
- Odd Rune Stalheim(author)
Export Metadata
| Title |
|
|---|---|
| Contributor | Nicholas Strzalkowski(author) |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ |
| Publisher | Open Book Publishers |
| Publication place | Cambridge, UK |
| Long abstract | Uncertainty in higher education is often framed as something to be controlled and minimized. The desire for certainty is reflected at all levels of the institution, including common approaches to learning outcomes, assessments, classroom expectations, student feedback, and employability metrics. Yet students and instructors encounter uncertainty as an essential feature of learning and lived experience. In this reflective paper, we introduce a Pedagogy of Productive Uncertainty that recognizes uncertainty as a generative condition that supports learning, not as a threat to be controlled. Drawing on our personal experience, we build on social constructivism and critical pedagogy to argue that uncertainty in higher education must be intentionally addressed through co-construction, shared intellectual risk, and a willingness to question dominant systems of knowledge. We present a three-axis model that places productive uncertainty at the intersection of instructional process, information complexity, and relationality. Through examples of our own teaching practices, we show how embracing uncertainty in our classrooms can foster curiosity and deepen engagement. In an increasingly complex world, we argue for the pedagogical and ethical necessity of embracing a framework of productive uncertainty. |
| Language | English (Original) |
| THEMA |
|
| BISAC |
|
| Keywords |
|
Contributors
Nicholas Strzalkowski
(author)Nicholas Strzalkowski (PhD) is an Associate Professor at Mount Royal University in Calgary, Canada, cross-appointed between Biology and General Education. Trained as a human sensorimotor neurophysiologist, his disciplinary research examines the sensory control of human movement. In parallel, he has been actively engaged in the scholarship of teaching and learning (SoTL) throughout his academic career. His SoTL work explores undergraduate science literacy and examines how uncertainty, compassion, and freewriting can foster deeper reflection and engagement with scientific ideas in the classroom. His dual scholarship focus reflects a commitment to viewing science as both a body of knowledge and a human practice. He is particularly committed to mentoring undergraduate researchers and helping them develop their own scientific voice. Across both research streams, he works collaboratively with students to co-create knowledge and advance both scientific understanding and evidence-informed practice in undergraduate education.
Sarah Hewitt
(author)Sarah Hewitt (PhD) is a professor in the Biology Department at Mount Royal University. Her two primary fields of scholarship include science communication and the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL). Her work in science communication has taken her around the world to work with dozens of researchers where she then creates multimedia stories about the work they do. She uses her experience in communication to engage students to participate in, contribute to, and produce an MRU science magazine. Her past SoTL work focused on the use of modified concept maps in enhancing learning and retention in STEM fields, and the value of structured interdisciplinary conversations to break down barriers between disciplines. Current projects include work on exam fairness, using freewriting and creative writing to teach in STEM classrooms, and investigating the role of uncertainty in academia. She values integrating both streams of her research directly into the classroom by providing unique opportunities for students to engage with science communication and teaching.
Michelle Yeo
(author)Michelle Yeo (PhD) is a professor, faculty developer, and teacher educator. She is the Academic Director of the teaching and learning centre, the Academic Development Centre (ADC) at Mount Royal University in Canada, in Treaty 7 territory. From 2017-2025 she directed the Mokakiiks Centre for Scholarship of Teaching and Learning. For the past two decades, Michelle has worked closely with faculty members thinking deeply about their teaching and learning practice. Her research interests in Scholarship of Teaching and Learning include student experiences of learning, scholarship of educational development, interpretive research methodologies, and decolonizing practices. In these roles, she invests herself in teaching and learning communities. Along with Janice Miller-Young and Karen Manarin, in 2023 she published a book length project, SoTL Research Methodologies: A Guide to Conceptualizing and Conducting the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning.
Odd Rune Stalheim
(author)Odd Rune Stalheim (PhD) holds a master’s in pedagogy and a PhD in innovation and higher education pedagogy. Stalheim is a professor of pedagogy. His interests and research focus on quality, innovation, and digital technology in teaching, with a strong emphasis on student learning and bildung. Passionate about pedagogy, philosophy, and SoTL, he explores how reflective, research-based practices enhance education.
