Evaluation as a mechanism to foster an equitable society in the Global South
- Steven Masvaure(editor)
- Takunda J Chirau(editor)
- Tebogo Fish(editor)
- Samukelisiwe Mkhize(editor)
- Candice Morkel(editor)
- Andiswa Neku(author)
- Angela Heucher(author)
- Caitlin Blaser Mapitsa(author)
- Jan Tobias Polak(author)
- Khumo Pule(author)
- Lea Smidt(author)
- Lena Taube(author)
- Lungiswa Zibi(author)
- Madri Jansen van Rensburg(author)
- Rose Cathy Azuba(author)
- Stanford Muhomba(author)
- Umali Saidi(author)
- Vongai Chibvongodze(author)
| Title | Evaluation as a mechanism to foster an equitable society in the Global South |
|---|---|
| Contributor | Steven Masvaure(editor) |
| Takunda J Chirau(editor) | |
| Tebogo Fish(editor) | |
| Samukelisiwe Mkhize(editor) | |
| Candice Morkel(editor) | |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2024.BK465 |
| Landing page | https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/465 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Steven Masvaure, Takunda Chirau, Tebogo Fish, Samukelisiwe Mkhize and Candice Morkel. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral right of the editors and authors has been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Publication place | Durbanville, Cape Town, South Africa |
| Published on | 2025-02-27 |
| Series |
|
| ISBN | 978-1-77995-326-1 (Paperback) |
| 978-1-77995-358-2 (Hardback) | |
| 978-1-77995-328-5 (PDF) | |
| 978-1-77995-327-8 (EPUB) | |
| Long abstract | This scholarly book is Volume 2 of a duology that seeks to stimulate conversations among development evaluators, commissioners of evaluations and development programme decision-makers about the role of evaluation in addressing inequality and fostering an equitable society in Africa. The book chapters explore the following questions: (1) Take stock of what we know about inequality – what inequality is in the African context, and how does it affect the lives of the citizens of African countries? (2) What does equitable evaluation mean? How can the concept of equitable evaluation be adopted in evaluation practice? (3) What lessons can be learnt from evaluations of interventions that address inequality at various levels (sectoral, programmatic and project) levels? (4) What epistemological transformation in evaluation practice is needed to achieve an equitable society? and (5) How have issues of inequality manifested within evaluation practice through organisations, institutions and international development? This book’s target audience is academics engaged in the field of developmental programmes in sub-Saharan Africa. |
| Print length | 250 pages (nulla+250+nulla) |
| Language | English (Original) |
| Dimensions | 170 x 244 mm | 6.692913385826772" x 9.606299212598426" (Paperback) |
| 170 x 244 mm | 6.692913385826772" x 9.606299212598426" (Hardback) | |
| Media | 7 illustrations |
| 10 tables | |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| Keywords |
|
| Funding |
Contents
- Caitlin Blaser Mapitsa
- Madri Jansen van Rensburg
- Umali Saidi
- Rose Cathy Azuba
| Landing Page | Full text URL | Platform | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/465(opens in new tab) | Landing page(opens in new tab) | https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/465(opens in new tab) | Full text URL(opens in new tab) | Publisher Website |
Contributors
Steven Masvaure
(editor)Steven Masvaure is a senior evaluation technical specialist at the University of the Witwatersrand. He holds a PhD in Development Studies. Steven possesses more than 15 years of working experience as a researcher and evaluator in the development sector across several African countries. He is an expert in strengthening country-led M&E systems in Anglophone Africa. His areas of interest include local government, climate change adaptation, food security, public employment programmes, social protection and M&E. He has also worked as an evaluator in several African countries and published research papers on food security transforming evaluation (Made in Africa Evaluation), adaptive management of climate change and national evaluation systems.
Takunda J Chirau
(editor)Takunda J Chirau is the deputy director at CLEAR-AA, and leads the Evaluation Systems Programme at the Centre. Chirau has a PhD in Sociology from Rhodes University. He has been working in the M&E discipline and has practised for more than 12 years. Chirau has conducted several National Evaluation Capacity Development (NECD) activities. Some of these activities have been carried out through the respective United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (UNICEF) country offices and East and Southern Africa regional offices. His contributions to the M&E discipline and profession are evident in countries like Kenya, Uganda, Zambia, Lesotho, Namibia, Botswana, Tanzania, Liberia and Zimbabwe, to mention a few. He is a former board member of the South African Monitoring and Evaluation Association (SAMEA).
Tebogo Fish
(editor)Tebogo Fish is a researcher and programme manager at CLEAR-AA, hosted by the Faculty of Commerce, Law and Management (CLM) at the University of the Witwatersrand. Fish holds a BA (Honours) degree in Psychology obtained from Stellenbosch University, and an MA degree in Research Psychology obtained from Wits University. Fish has been working in the M&E field for eight years. Her research interests include interventions and best practices in addressing social issues in Africa (such as poverty, unemployment, inequality, homelessness, etc.), discourses on and public sector interventions to mitigate mental illness and neurodevelopment challenges in Africa. She also has research interests in topics important to the M&E field in Africa, including culturally and contextually relevant approaches to the M&E in Africa such as Made in Africa Evaluation. Fish is also a supervisor of several students in the MA of Management in Governance (Public and Development M&E) course, and a sessional lecturer for the postgraduate diploma in Management Public and Development Sector M&E course, both at Wits University. She has authored and co-authored five published peer-reviewed journal articles on various M&E-related topics including Made in Africa Evaluation, evaluation capacity strengthening, African Voluntary Organizations for Professional Evaluations (VOPEs), etc. Fish is a co-editor of Part 1 of this book (https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2023.BK459(opens in new tab)) and has also authored and co-authored three chapters in the book. Fish is also a co-author of a book chapter in an upcoming book by the Center for Evaluation (CEval).
Samukelisiwe Mkhize
(editor)Samukelisiwe Mkhize is a researcher at CLEAR-AA, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa. She holds an MSocSc in Policy and Development Studies from the University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN). Mkhize has extensive experience in climate adaptation and mitigation in smallholder systems, supporting the development of climate-smart agriculture decision support systems. Her current research interests are the conceptualisation of climate justice in complex socio-ecological systems and public policy responses to climate adaptation and mitigation in Africa.
Candice Morkel
(editor)Candice Morkel (PhD) is the academic head of the IPDET Programme at the Zentrum für universitäre Weiterbildung at the University of Bern, Switzerland, and is the past director of CLEAR-AA. She has nearly more than 25 years’ experience in government, academia and the non-profit sector, specialising in M&E and public policy. For eight years, Morkel focused primarily on working with governments and development partners across the African continent to help build better systems of evidence production and use towards strengthening national evaluation systems. As the IPDET Programme HoD, her focus is on ensuring the growth of the globally recognised evaluation capacity development programme, expanding its reach and sustaining its legacy. She has published peer-reviewed articles, book chapters and edited books on M&E, and supervises local and international MA and PhD students in evaluation. She is a legacy board member of the African Evaluation Association, legacy chair of the South African M&E Association and is legacy board member of the International Evaluation Academy.
Andiswa Neku
(author)Andiswa Neku is a programme associate at the Centre for Learning on Evaluation and Results, Anglophone Africa (CLEAR-AA), where she plays a pivotal role in enhancing the effectiveness of monitoring and evaluation (M&E) practices across the region. With a solid academic foundation, Neku holds both a BA (Law) and International Relations and a Bachelor of Laws (LLB) from the University of the Witwatersrand. Currently, she is furthering her expertise by pursuing a postgraduate diploma in Public Management, specialising in M&E. This additional qualification underscores her drive to contribute to the field of public management with a nuanced perspective. Her educational journey reflects a commitment to understanding the complex interplay between legal frameworks and international dynamics. Neku’s unique blend of analytical skills and legal acumen enables her to approach M&E with a critical eye and a comprehensive understanding of the regulatory and procedural aspects of the field. Her background in law enriches her ability to navigate the complexities of policy evaluation and implementation, ensuring that projects not only meet their objectives but also adhere to legal and ethical standards. Passionate about applying evaluation principles to real-world projects, Neku is committed to driving impactful change through rigorous and insightful evaluations. Her work at CLEAR-AA involves collaborating with various stakeholders to promote evidence-based decision-making and enhance the effectiveness of development initiatives. By bridging the gap between theory and practice, Neku is making significant contributions to the field of monitoring and evaluation, aiming to foster sustainable development and positive social impact in Anglophone Africa.
Angela Heucher
(author)Angela Heucher is a senior evaluator and team leader in the sustainable economic and social development department at the German Institute for Development Evaluation (DEval), Germany. Heucher holds a PhD in Political Science obtained from the University of Potsdam and an MA in Political Science from Freie Universität Berlin. Heucher’s research interests encompass gender equality and human rights, post-conflict contexts, multilateral development cooperation and global food security governance. Heucher has published on these topics and co-authored evaluation reports, concretely on the promotion of sustainable supply chains and human rights in German development policy with a focus on private sector and financial system development and on supporting gender equality in post-conflict contexts.
Caitlin Blaser Mapitsa
(author)Caitlin Blaser Mapitsa is a senior lecturer, holding a PhD in Migration and Displacement from the University of the Witwatersrand’s African Centre for Migration and Society. She received an MA from the same institution, a BA from Wellesley College in International Relations and French, and a postgraduate diploma from the University of Stellenbosch in Monitoring and Evaluation. She is also the research director at the School. Mapitsa has worked as an evaluator in civil society, with Resilient Waters evaluating efforts to foster climate resilience in the Okavango and Limpopo river basins, as well as establishing learning systems with the Global Call to Action Against Poverty. She also worked with the CLEARAA, supporting efforts to strengthen M&E systems within public sector institutions across the region through peer learning. Mapitsa’s research interests focus on two areas – the first is transboundary governance, of both land and people. She is interested in understanding what drives change in complex social and ecological systems, and which tools can best help us understand these changes. The second is on building contextually relevant evaluation approaches, and how evaluation can be a tool to align institutional practice with values systems and developmental objectives.
Jan Tobias Polak
(author)Tobias Polak is a senior evaluator and team leader in the human rights and civil society department at the German Institute for Development Evaluation (Deval), Germany. Polak holds a PhD in Social Sciences and Economics obtained from the University of Vienna, Austria. His research interests encompass evaluation research, evaluation methodology and methods as well as human rights and aid effectiveness. He has published on these topics and co-authored evaluation reports. Polak is part of the executive board of the German Evaluation Society DEval.
Khumo Pule
(author)Khumo Pule is a M&E officer at CLEAR-AA, Faculty of Commerce, Law, and Management, University of the Witwatersrand. She is completing her MA in M&E, having finished coursework, and holds a postgraduate diploma in M&E. Pule has experience in enhancing evidence use for African Parliaments and strengthening M&E systems in both the public and private sectors. Additionally, she has extensive experience in conducting evaluations in the education and information and communications technology sectors.
Lea Smidt
(author)Lea Smidt is a senior policy officer and data scientist at the Data Lab of the German Federal Ministry of Economic Cooperation and Development. Smidt holds an MSc in European Studies obtained from Maastricht University, an MA in Political Sciences obtained from the University of Cologne and a BA in Political Science and African Studies from Sciences Po Paris. Smidt is a Government Analytics Fellow of the World Bank and recipient of the Daniël Heinsius Prize for the best MA thesis in Political Sciences awarded by the Dutch-Flemish Political Science Association. Her research interests lie in the fields of human rights, development policy, quantitative methods and data use in public administration.
Lena Taube
(author)Lena Taube is an evaluator at the German Institute for Development Cooperation in the Department of Civil Society, Human Rights, Germany. Taube holds an MSc in Sociology, Politics and Social Research and an MA in Empowerment Studies obtained from the University of Cologne and the University of Applied Science Düsseldorf. Taube is currently working as an evaluator at DEval, where she conducts evaluations with a focus on human rights. She also works on human rights-based approaches to evaluation and how aspects such as human rights and gender could be integrated throughout the evaluation process and content.
Lungiswa Zibi
(author)Lungiswa Zibi is an evaluator with over a decade of experience in the fields of M&E and strategic planning. Throughout her career, she has been instrumental in advancing evaluation systems and frameworks across various key governmental departments in South Africa. Her notable contributions began at the Department of Environmental Affairs, where she played a pivotal role in developing and implementing evaluation mechanisms to assess environmental programmes. Zibi further extended her impact at the Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation. Here, she played a pivotal role in establishing, managing and reviewing the National Evaluation System (NES). At the Department of Science and Innovation, Zibi spearheaded the institutionalisation of the departmental evaluation system.
Currently, Zibi leads the evaluation efforts at the Department of Tourism. In this role, she focuses on enhancing strategic decision-making and policy development to foster sustainable growth within the tourism sector. Her management in this area ensures that evaluation processes are integral to shaping policies that promote economic development and environmental sustainability. Zibi’s career is marked by her dedication to improving public sector performance through rigorous evaluation practices. Her ability to integrate evaluation into strategic planning has made her a key figure in shaping policies that drive sustainable development.
Madri Jansen van Rensburg
(author)Jansen van Rensburg is a research and consulting psychologist doing research, M&E and organisational development work. She mainly works in countries in East and Southern Africa. She works on individual, group, community and country levels and has conducted various multi-country and cross-cultural studies including studies across all African regions. Van Rensburg’s research interests include children’s rights, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and gender, using participatory and mixed-method approaches. She has a special interest in the resilience of communities and individuals facing adverse conditions. She has completed various evaluation studies for public, private and civil society.
Rose Cathy Azuba
(author)Rose Azuba is a senior lecturer in the Department of Livestock and Industrial Resources at Makerere University Kampala, Uganda. Azuba holds an MA degree (MADEM) in Development Evaluation and Management from the University of Antwerp, Belgium; a PhD in Viral Immunology; an MA of Science in Veterinary Medicine (MSc) and a Bachelors in Veterinary Medicine (BVM). Azuba has 15 years’ experience in evaluation and institutional performance assessments, participating in or leading over 40 national and international assignments in several countries, including Uganda, Kenya, Tanzania, Ethiopia, Ghana, Nigeria, Swaziland, Malawi, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Cote D’Ivoire in Africa and Thailand, Myanmar, New Zealand and the Czech Republic.
Stanford Muhomba
(author)Stanford Muhomba holds an MPhil in M&E and is currently finalising his PhD in Development Studies, focusing on gender and equity-focused evaluations. With over 15 years of professional experience, he serves as the director at Citofield Consulting, where he has been involved in more than 50 evaluation and research projects. Muhomba has developed expertise in M&E methodologies throughout his career, specialising in integrating gender and equity perspectives. He is proficient in using innovative tools and techniques to enhance the accuracy and utility of evaluation findings, including mixed-methods approaches that combine qualitative and quantitative data to provide a holistic view of programme outcomes. Throughout his career, Stanford has worked with a diverse range of organisations and stakeholders, including government agencies, non-profit organisations and private corporations. His evaluations have covered a wide array of sectors, such as health care, education, agriculture and economic development. This breadth of experience has equipped Muhomba with a comprehensive understanding of the challenges and opportunities associated with evaluations in various contexts. A significant aspect of Muhomba’s career is his focus on capacity building and knowledge sharing. He regularly conducts training workshops and seminars to equip other professionals with the skills necessary for effective M&E.
Umali Saidi
(author)Umali Saidi is the postgraduate studies manager (Research and Innovation Division), senior lecturer and the Editor-in-Chief of The Dyke Journal – a multidisciplinary journal at the Midlands State University, Zimbabwe. He is also an associate editor of the African Evaluation Journal. Saidi holds a PhD in Applied Linguistics and is a staunch and avid researcher with interests in knowledge management and indigenous knowledge systems, especially as linked to M&E. His current research interests are around epistemes and how indigenous knowledge-based evaluation systems in Africa can support changes in governance for sustainable development on the African continent.
Vongai Chibvongodze
(author)Vongai Chibvongodze is currently a student studying towards an MA of Economic Science at the University of the Witwatersrand. Chibvongodzo holds a BA of Economic Science with Honours and a BA of Commerce in Politics, Philosophy and Economics obtained from the University of the Witwatersrand. Chibvongodze is the recipient of the Postgraduate Merit Award and Certificates of First Class in Politics and Philosophy awarded by the University of the Witwatersrand in the years 2021 and 2018 to 2019, respectively. Chibvongodze focuses on work and research in evaluation, macroeconomics, development economics and econometrics. Her honours thesis was centred around the investigation of whether the earnings gap between black women and other social groups in South Africa has improved in the post-Apartheid era. The purpose was to track the socio-economic progress of previously disadvantaged groups in the country while identifying possible underlying and persistent causes of the remaining earning gap. Chibvongodze is currently working on corporate and investment banking operations at the Standard Bank Group. She previously worked within the Advisory division of the M&E consultancy Data Innovators, working within Digital Data Solutions (DDS) and M&E services. She also worked as a programme associate at CLEAR-AA. Chibvongodze's has contributed to numerous influential projects, including evaluations for the Tiger Brands Foundation’s In-School Breakfast Programme, Bezos Earth Fund’s climate initiatives and MasterCard Foundation M&E framework development for their Young Impact Associates programme.
