Export Metadata
| Title | Interpretive frames, judgement and action |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Radboud University Press |
| Publication place | Nijmegen |
| Published on | 2022-05-31 |
| Long abstract | One central element of the VALIDATE approach is the recognition that an HTA needs to take into how the variety of actors involved in its object (caregivers, patients, policymakers, researchers, pharma-firms etc.) views on what is relevant, plausible, and valid with respect to the use of health technology. This chapter is focused on what is called in the policy sciences ‘interpretive frames’, a concept to systematically denote such ‘views.’ It starts with a discussion of how interpretive frames help understand that different HTA researchers may adopt different outcome measures, and that these often do not take into account what outcomes are deemed important in clinical practice. Once the nature and role of interpretive frames have been pointed out, the chapter will discuss a method for systematically reconstructing and critically scrutinizing these frames and the way they are chosen. Finally, it will outline the ramifications of the often witnessed disjoint between HTA and clinical practice or policy making, and ways to pre-empt that disjoint. These various notions will be applied to the NIPT case. Key message of this chapter: Different actors (doctors, policy makers, hospitals, patients, manufacturers et cetera) look into a health issue and associated health technology from different interpretive frames, and hence define problems and judge technologies different. Even within these professions different interpretive frames exist, and some may be underrepresented. Thus, first, reconstructing and scrutinizing interpretive frames may therefore help gain a more critical view on the object of the HTA, e.g., introducing a different comparator. Second, as different actors prevail at the macro-, meso-, and micro-level, an HTA made at one level must take into account interpretive frames from the level that it seeks to inform. Under circumstances, this may have important methodical ramifications, toward forms of participative or deliberative HTA. After reading this chapter you should: know the concept of interpretive frame and its rationale; understand how interpretive frames shape outcome measures, comparators, and other key elements of an HTA; be able to systematically reconstruct and critically scrutinize interpretive frames and; understand, on that basis, how to make an HTA optimally useful for clinical practice or policy making. |
