A philosophical summary of the VALIDATE approach
- Bart Bloemen(author)
- Gert Jan van der Wilt(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | A philosophical summary of the VALIDATE approach |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Radboud University Press |
| Publication place | Nijmegen |
| Published on | 2022-05-31 |
| Long abstract | Because the VALIDATE approach is based upon the premise that normative analysis is, and should be, an integral part of HTA, it needs to address the possibilities and limitations of reaching agreement on normative issues in the context of health policy. Although a strict fact/value dichotomy is criticized (Chapter 1 and Chapter 2), and the plurality of methods for conducting normative analysis is recognized (Chapter 5), there is still an explanation needed on how the VALIDATE approach can offer a legitimate, and reliable, way of answering policy relevant questions on health technology. This chapter attempts to provide such explanation, based on the philosophical tradition of pragmatism. Specifically, it will offer a critical examination of the position of moral scepticism and suggest how it can be overcome by applying elements of pragmatism to the practice of health technology assessment (HTA). Especially the relation between pragmatism and the concept of interpretive frames (introduced in Chapter 3) will be clarified. Key message of this chapter: the philosophy of VALIDATE, partly based on pragmatism, is that normative issues that arise in the context of HTA can be addressed in a rational way. After reading this chapter, you should be able to understand that the VALIDATE approach can best be conceived as a framework for evaluating health technology that is inspired by, but not synonymous to, pragmatist philosophy. |
