Chapter 6: Discipline from an indigenous knowledge systems perspective (Dealing with discipline and ill-discipline from traditional and modern perspectives in educational contexts)
- Mncedise N. Thambe(author)
- Josef de Beer(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | Chapter 6: Discipline from an indigenous knowledge systems perspective (Dealing with discipline and ill-discipline from traditional and modern perspectives in educational contexts) |
|---|---|
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2021.BK204.06 |
| Landing page | https://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/204 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Johan Botha. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral right of the author has been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Publication place | Durbanville, Cape Town, South Africa |
| Published on | 2022-02-17 |
| Long abstract | Discipline has always been a cornerstone of most African traditions, customs and rituals. Without discipline, we do not have a sense of focus, which is pivotal to achieving set goals or required outcomes in the classroom, workplace or broader society. Many issues pose challenges and threaten school education in South Africa. Learner ill-discipline and unruly behaviour in schools are just some of these. The reality is that poor discipline erodes the affordances of school education and could lead to learning spaces that do not optimally foster the development of 21st-century skills. In this chapter, the focus is on learner and initiated youth (initiation schools) discipline and ill-discipline. Learner discipline and ill-discipline are pertinent challenges that the South African education system faces as far as improving the quality of education and creating a more conducive and engaging learning environment. In this chapter, the authors explore how ‘discipline’ has always been maintained in two important traditional customs, namely being initiated (rite of passage) and being inducted to become a traditional doctor or a diviner. In both rites of passage, the initiates follow a set of rules that instils discipline. Elders are sources of experiential knowledge in both. As initiates into manhood, the young men are instructed to abstain from sexual activities at least two to three months before the rite. They are also instructed to follow a prescribed diet and maintain high levels of discipline by not drinking water or eating salty food for seven days after the operation. Initiates are taught how to discipline each other and how to protect each other as brothers. They are assigned different social responsibilities, such as being part of the traditional disciplinary committee that sits on community cases where they must decide as a collective on disciplinary measures, which must be applied in different social community cases, the building of schools and the protection of the community (‘morafe’) in times of war. Collective responsibility is instilled as a highest level of discipline. However, the authors also highlight practices such as ‘ukumetsba’, or ‘ukosula’, which should be questioned in a country that staggers under a wave of gender-based violence. The leitmotif of this chapter is a systematic review of literature on traditional discipline of learners or initiates, from an indigenous knowledge systems perspective. The authors also argue that these practices are often ‘other-directed’ rather than ‘self-directed’. Self-discipline entails assuming social and moral responsibility for one’s own actions, and it should be driven by one’s own volition and not because of a fear of punishment. In the conclusion of this chapter, the authors highlight this conundrum utilising third-generation Cultural-Historical Activity Theory (CHAT) as a lens. It highlights both the good and the bad associated with traditional initiation schools and how it might either promote or suppress discipline in public schools. |
| Print length | 33 pages |
| Language | English (Original) |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| Keywords |
|
| Funding |
Contributors
Mncedise N. Thambe
(author)Mncedise N. Thambe, an Indigenous Knowledge Holder and a traditionalist co-researcher in the National Research Foundation’s research project, presented his first academic paper at the ESTE Conference in 2016. He is a seasoned playwright, author, theatre director, trained actor, translator and facilitator in the performing arts and tourism sector. In addition, he is a trained and registered multi-award-winning tourist guide under the culture category. He has published a stage play ‘On appeal’ in an anthology of short stories with other writers titled Bloody satisfied in 2013. He has written and directed seven stage plays and acted in more than 40 theatre plays, two television dramas and one soapie – Rhythm City – playing a controversial character in the initiation story. He was a senior tourist guide and educational officer at Mphebatho Cultural Museum from 2013 until 2018.
Josef de Beer
(author)Josef de Beer is a research professor in the Research Unit Self-Directed Learning, in the Faculty of Education, North-West University. His main research focus is on the affordances of indigenous knowledge to enhance self-directed learning in the natural sciences. Accolades include the National Research Foundation ‘Excellence in Science Engagement’, award that Josef received in 2019, and the Education Association of South Africa’s Medal of Honour in 2020. He is the principal investigator in a Fuchs Foundation funded project, ‘Teachers without Borders’, which is a Finalist in the NSTF-South 32 2020 Awards. He has published at national and international level, and acts as a supervisor for post-graduate students.
