Chapter 8: Making collective decisions: Clinical competency committees
- Louis Jenkins(author)
- Mulimisi Ramavhuya(author)
- Richard Cooke(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | Chapter 8: Making collective decisions: Clinical competency committees |
|---|---|
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2026.BK586.08 |
| Landing page | http://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/586 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Tasleem Ras, Sumaiya Adam, Louis Jenkins, Lionel Green-Thompson and Vanessa Burch. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral rights of the editors and authors have been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Publication place | Durbanville, Cape Town, South Africa |
| Published on | 2026-09-30 |
| Long abstract | This chapter continues from the previous chapters and explains the place of clinical competency committees (CCCs) in workplace-based assessment (WBA). Imagine a steady flow of evidence of learning from the clinical workplace within a trainee–supervisor interaction captured in a portfolio, which is then assessed by a CCC. Clinical competency committees play a pivotal role in competency-based medical education (CBME) by synthesising multiple sources of assessment data to make high-stakes decisions about trainee progression. The chapter explores the structure, function and decision-making processes of CCCs, emphasising their collective responsibility in ensuring fair, transparent and defensible judgements of trainee competence. Framed within an Ubuntu praxis of interconnectedness and collaboration, it explores group decision-making, consensus-building, mitigation of cognitive biases and strategies to enhance the trustworthiness of CCC decisions, such as the use of structured frameworks and narrative assessment data. It provides guidance to medical educators on optimising CCC functioning to support both trainee development and patient safety. Clinical competency committees are positioned as critical mechanisms for translating individual assessments into meaningful, programme-level judgements that uphold the integrity of medical training. Drawing from evidence-based best practices and regulatory frameworks, the chapter highlights how group dynamics, faculty development and entrustment decisions intersect within CCC deliberations. Ultimately, this chapter serves as a guide for academic leaders, programme directors and committee members seeking to strengthen competency-based assessment and ensure the accountability and fairness of trainee progression decisions. |
| Print length | 16 pages |
| Language | English (Original) |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| Keywords |
|
Contributors
Louis Jenkins
(author)Louis Jenkins is appointed in the Division of Family Medicine and Primary Care at Stellenbosch University in South Africa and holds an honorary associate professor appointment in the Department of Family, Community and Emergency Care at UCT. He is a clinician and Head of Clinical Unit of the Department of Family and Emergency Medicine at George Regional Hospital in the Garden Route and Central Karoo districts of South Africa, where he has been working for the last 25 years. His PhD focused on developing a national portfolio for Family Medicine. Jenkins headed up a working group in the National College of Family Physicians that developed entrustable professional activities (EPAs) for postgraduate family medicine training in the country. He led the development and implementation of the national ePoL of the South African Academy of Family Physicians. He is the chair of the national Clinical Competency Committee of the College of Family Physicians and has published on work-based assessment, leadership development, palliative care and health worker resilience.
Mulimisi Ramavhuya
(author)Mulimisi Ramavhuya qualified as a family physician with an MMed in 2009. He is currently Head of Unit, Family Medicine, in the Limpopo Department of Health and the University of Limpopo and Family Medicine module co-ordinator for MBChB 6 in Limpopo province, South Africa. He has contributed to curriculum development for Family Medicine specialist training in South Africa and co-leads the ongoing review and transformation process for the national assessment of medical specialist trainees.
Richard Cooke
(author)Richard Cooke holds qualifications in finance (Bachelor of Business Science) and medicine, having spent his initial professional years in the financial sector before transitioning wholly into the health sector. He subsequently specialised in Family Medicine, earning Fellowship of the College of Family Physicians (FCFP) and an MMed (Wits) in Family Medicine. The Department of Family Medicine and Primary Care is home to Divisions of Family Medicine, Emergency Medicine, Rural Health, Clinical Associates and Sports and Exercise Medicine, where Cooke holds overall responsibility for the respective undergraduate and postgraduate health sciences academic programmes in five districts across two provinces. Cooke chairs the Graduate Entry Medical Programme Curriculum Committee (GEMP 3&4) and is the Wits Nelson Mandela Fidel Castro Collaboration Director. He chairs the Wits Adler Museum of Medicine Advisory Board. He is a member of the SACOMD WBA National Steering Committee and the SACOMD Private Health Sciences Training Task Team. He is an examiner for the Fellowship of the College of Family Physicians of South Africa (FCFP [SA]).
