Trust and entrustability in medical specialist training in South Africa: An Ubuntu-inspired pedagogy
- Tasleem Ras(editor)
- Sumaiya Adam(editor)
- Louis Jenkins(editor)
- Lionel Green-Thompson(editor)
- Vanessa Burch(editor)
- Abegail Dlova(author)
- Brian Gardner(author)
- Daniel Nel(author)
- Gert van Zyl(author)
- Gerda Botha(author)
- Madeleine Muller(author)
- Mothahadini Mawela(author)
- Mulimisi Ramavhuya(author)
- Richard Cooke(author)
- Sa’ad Lahri(author)
- Tashneem Harris(author)
- Thakadu Mamashela(author)
- Veena S Singaram(author)
- Waseela Khan(author)
| Title | Trust and entrustability in medical specialist training in South Africa: An Ubuntu-inspired pedagogy |
|---|---|
| Contributor | Tasleem Ras(editor) |
| Sumaiya Adam(editor) | |
| Louis Jenkins(editor) | |
| Lionel Green-Thompson(editor) | |
| Vanessa Burch(editor) | |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2026.BK586 |
| Landing page | http://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/586 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Tasleem Ras, Sumaiya Adam, Louis Jenkins, Lionel Green-Thompson and Vanessa Burch. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral rights of the editors and authors have been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Publication place | Durbanville, Cape Town, South Africa |
| Published on | 2026-09-30 |
| ISBN | 978-1-997449-64-5 (Paperback) |
| 978-1-997449-67-6 (PDF) | |
| 978-1-997449-66-9 (EPUB) | |
| Long abstract | The medical specialist training landscape in South Africa (SA) is grounded in a tradition of learning in the clinical workplace for at least four years, with a single exit examination assessing clinical competence, knowledge and complex clinical reasoning. However, given the broad scope of specialist practice, it is impossible to assess all aspects of training in this single assessment. Consequently, it is not possible to make a categorical statement on the holistic clinical competence of trainees using the data derived from the current assessment model. A rational solution to this dilemma could be the introduction of formal continuous assessments within the workplace, aptly called workplace-based assessments (WBA). As the name implies, this is based on the overall performance of trainees in real-life situations. These assessments need to be well planned, implemented by appropriately trained supervisors, reported in a manner that facilitates defensible progression decisions about trainees and allow faculty to make final decisions about trainees’ clinical competence across a range of domains that characterise the specific discipline. The evidence for the impact of this type of complex intervention on trainee performance, assessment quality and impact on skills development has been well documented in high-income countries, but less so in low-middle-income countries globally and even less in Africa. This book addresses the crucial gap within the literature on WBA in medical specialist training in the context of African and low-middle-income countries. The primary aim was to present a socially accountable praxis of WBA in SA by bringing together locally generated research that described early initiatives at implementing WBA, key elements from the global literature and the lived experiences of the authors who are all deeply involved in various aspects of specialist training. Using a realist perspective, the authors foreground data that describes the SA context, given the stark inequality across training sites and the attitudes and capabilities of supervisors and trainees who labour under immense clinical workloads. They employ an Ubuntu perspective to frame their reflections on the local and global literature, infused with their own experiences, which necessarily elevates the role of workplace relationships and social dynamics as these impact the learning and teaching environment. What emerges from each chapter is a uniquely African proposition for medical specialist training, offering new ways of teaching and learning that are sensitive to the emotions, hierarchies, sensitivities and cultural dynamics that are typical of a diverse demographic context, without departing from the high-stakes technical competence required for medical specialist practice. This has implications for how health educational systems are configured and how faculty are trained. The hypothesised impact in the short term would be more accurate assessments of clinical competence, in the medium term, a positive change in the socio-cultural dynamic of the clinical learning spaces and in the long term, the emergence of clinical services that produce better holistic outcomes for staff and patients. |
| Print length | 240 pages (nulla+240+nulla) |
| Language | English (Original) |
| Dimensions | 170 x 244 mm | 6.692913385826772" x 9.606299212598426" (Paperback) |
| Media | 37 illustrations |
| 19 tables | |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| Keywords |
|
Contents
- Tasleem Ras
Contributors
Tasleem Ras
(editor)Tasleem Ras is a specialist Family Physician who has interests in health care systems, non-communicable diseases and postgraduate medical education. In addition to his clinical specialist qualifications, he holds a PhD in Health Sciences Education, with a particular focus on specialist training in resource-constrained contexts. His current appointment is associate professor, Head of Department of Family, Community and Emergency Care and GlaxoSmithKline Director of Primary Health Care at UCT.
He led the development of clinical examinations for the College of Family Physicians of South Africa for almost a decade and played a central role in incorporating communication technology into these high-stakes assessments. During this time, he also convened the specialist training programmes for Family Medicine at UCT. Prior to his work in specialist training, Ras worked as a consultant clinician in urban and rural primary care settings, as well as in undergraduate medical education as a senior lecturer.
Sumaiya Adam
(editor)Sumaiya Adam is a clinician-scientist and professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at the University of Pretoria, South Africa, where she specialises in Maternal–Foetal Medicine. She has been actively involved in both undergraduate and postgraduate training and curriculum development, with particular focus on EPAs and WBA. Her work includes participation in national task teams, academic committees and professional bodies, contributing to efforts to strengthen clinical training and assessment in South Africa.
In addition to her educational contributions, she leads a diabetes-in-pregnancy clinic and engages in research on maternal health and non-communicable diseases. She collaborates with local and international colleagues and contributes to networks such as International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics and World Health Organization (WHO) working groups. As a supervisor and mentor of postgraduate students, she values shared learning and collective scholarship and remains committed to advancing both clinical care and medical education in her field.
Louis Jenkins
(editor)Louis Jenkins is appointed in the Division of Family Medicine and Primary Care at Stellenbosch University in South Africa and holds an honorary associate professor appointment in the Department of Family, Community and Emergency Care at UCT. He is a clinician and Head of Clinical Unit of the Department of Family and Emergency Medicine at George Regional Hospital in the Garden Route and Central Karoo districts of South Africa, where he has been working for the last 25 years. His PhD focused on developing a national portfolio for Family Medicine. Jenkins headed up a working group in the National College of Family Physicians that developed entrustable professional activities (EPAs) for postgraduate family medicine training in the country. He led the development and implementation of the national ePoL of the South African Academy of Family Physicians. He is the chair of the national Clinical Competency Committee of the College of Family Physicians and has published on work-based assessment, leadership development, palliative care and health worker resilience.
Lionel Green-Thompson
(editor)Lionel Green-Thompson has served as Dean of the Faculty of Health Sciences at UCT since March 2020. Prior to this appointment, he was Dean of the School of Medicine at SMU from 2018 to 2020 and Assistant Dean for Teaching, Learning and Undergraduate Affairs at Wits from 2014 to 2018. He is a co-author of the Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf) Consensus Report: Reconceptualising HPE in South Africa. He is a specialist anaesthesiologist and completed a PhD in 2014 entitled: The nature of social accountability in South African medical education and practice. Green-Thompson served as the Chairperson of the SACOMD (2022–2023) and is currently co-chairing a National Steering Committee with the CMSA on the development of WBAs for specialist medical education. He is interested in the assessment of clinical competency, professional identity formation (PIF), transformative education and social accountability. A long-time councillor, he was SAAHE national co-chairperson for the 2010–2013 triennium and co-chaired the national conference held at Wits in 2010 titled ‘Making Education Matter’. Other affiliations include serving on the board of the Rural Health Advocacy Project and Towards Unity for Health (TUFH). He is currently the Vice Secretary General for TUFH in the term 2023–2027. He is a member of AMEE and serves on the AMEE Research Committee, currently chairing the Network for Medical Education in Resource Constrained Environments. In addition, he co-chairs the International Social Accountability Accreditation Steering Committee.
Vanessa Burch
(editor)Vanessa Burch, the first woman Chair of Clinical Medicine at UCT, has more than 30 years of experience as a clinician-educator and HPE scholar. Currently, she is Executive Director of Education and Assessment at the CMSA. In this position, she plays a critical leadership role in all specialist and sub-specialist examinations conducted in South Africa. She holds a PhD in HPE, has received numerous awards for academic excellence, four lifetime awards for teaching excellence and has authored more than 100 peer-reviewed publications and book chapters. She is also a fellow of the Foundation for Advancement of International Medical Education and Research (FAIMER) in the United States and was awarded a Teaching at University fellowship from the Council for Higher Education in South Africa.
Abegail Dlova
(author)Abegail Dlova is a lecturer and a pathologist at the Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University (SMU) and at Dr George Mukhari Academic Laboratory, National Health Laboratory Service, both located in South Africa. Dlova has the following qualifications: Bachelor of Science (BSc) (University of Fort Hare, South Africa), Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery (MBChB), Master of Medicine (MMed) (Haemat) (SMU), Postgraduate Diploma in Health Professions Education (PGDip HPE) (University of Cape Town [UCT], South Africa). Dlova’s areas of research interest are morphology and coagulation diagnostics, as well as HPE. Dlova has mentored and supervised research for several scientists and medical trainees for BSc Honours, Master of Science (MSc) and MMed. Dlova serves as an SMU representative on the national steering committee for workplace-based assessment (WBA), participates in several local academic planning and examination committees and is also a member of the school board at SMU. Dlova has presented in local and national awareness campaign initiatives as well as conferences for rare diseases, especially bleeding disorders.
Brian Gardner
(author)Brian Gardner trained as an anaesthesiologist and practised as a specialist at the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits), South Africa, circuit from 2000. He was the Head of Department of Anaesthesia and Pain Management at Helen Joseph Hospital, South Africa, from 2019 until 2024. Thereafter, he joined the Education and Assessment team at the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa (CMSA) as a specialist in assessment, while continuing to practise anaesthesiology part-time.
Daniel Nel
(author)Daniel Nel is a general surgeon and senior lecturer at UCT and Groote Schuur Hospital, South Africa, where he serves as the programme convener for postgraduate training in General Surgery. He holds a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in surgical education and has a special interest in assessment. He has led the development of the specifications of a digital electronic portfolio of learning (ePoL) that will be used to track medical specialist training in South Africa and co-leads an initiative aimed at enhancing the research skills of medical specialist trainees.
Gert van Zyl
(author)Gert van Zyl currently holds the position of Dean in the Faculty of Health Sciences University of the Free State (UFS), South Africa. He is an Association of Medical Education Europe (AMEE) Inaugural Fellow. Van Zyl engaged in Southern African Association of Health Educationalists (SAAHE) activities and has been Chairperson of SAAHE National for four years. Van Zyl has served in the past on several of the Medical and Dental Board committees and on the Health Professions Council of South Africa. He also contributed to teaching, research and service delivery on an academic level and was recognised by the university for his contributions on a national and international level. He has contributed to more than 20 articles in the last five years and has supervised more than 20 PhD students and a number of Master’s degree students. Van Zyl has been the recipient of a number of International and National awards, including a certificate of appreciation of service in 2016: Health Professions Council of South Africa; Fellowship of AMEE (2015); Deputy Vice Councillor’s Award for Community Engagement (2013); and taken up in the ‘Hall of Fame’ of the Postgraduate School of UFS for work done as researcher and study leader. He is a qualified Family Medicine Specialist with another five postgraduate qualifications. He served on the Board of the Council of Health Services Accreditation of Southern Africa in distinct positions. In addition, he served in 2024 as Chair of the South African Committee of Medical Deans (SACOMD) and on the Executive Committee of SACOMD.
Gerda Botha
(author)Gerda Botha is the Academic Project Leader of the School of Medicine at SMU. She has extensive experience in curriculum design and academic planning of curricula in the School of Medicine, including subspecialist training programmes. Botha is a member of various governance structures at the school and committees of the Senate, and she also drives the Learning Opportunities, Objectives and Outcome Platform mapping and related educational research in the school. She is seasoned in the design and development of decentralised platforms for training and early patient exposure for undergraduate medical students.
Her research interests are mainly in health professional education, focusing on curriculum mapping, social responsiveness, module integration in medical education and interprofessional medical education.
Madeleine Muller
(author)Madeleine Muller is a family physician at Cecilia Makiwane Hospital in Mdantsane, South Africa, and a senior lecturer at Walter Sisulu University, South Africa. She provides clinical services and teaches and mentors medical students, registrars and medical officers. Muller graduated with a Master’s in Health Professional Education from Stellenbosch University in March 2025 and is enrolled to begin her PhD in 2027.
Muller is convenor for the CMSA Diploma in HIV Management, and she serves on the CMSA Senate. Muller is part of the National CMSA/SACOMD committee responsible for implementing WBAs in postgraduate medical education and is one of the facilitators rolling out the Supervisor Workplace Assessment and Teaching Training for clinical supervisors across the 10 South African medical universities.
Muller is on the steering committee for the South African Association of Health Educationalists Eastern Cape Chapter and is an executive committee member of the Rural Doctors Association of Southern Africa, where she oversees the mentoring portfolio and manages the Rural Onboarding programme. She serves on the executive board of the Professional Association of Transgender Health in South Africa.
Mothahadini Mawela
(author)Mothahadini Mawela is the Dean of the School of Dentistry at SMU and the former Head of the Department of Paediatrics and Child Health at SMU and Dr George Mukhari Academic Hospital, South Africa. Mawela is an associate professor who has spent her entire professional career as an academic clinician, with a strong interest in health science education. Her academic and research interests include student support and student success, patient safety, quality improvement, vaccines and paediatric HIV. She has a keen interest in the mental health and wellbeing of health care providers, academics and students. She is a scholar of leadership, in particular, Women in Leadership. Mawela is currently a mentor, supervisor and co-supervisor for Master’s students in Paediatrics and in Dentistry. She serves on national committees and ministerial advisory committees, and she is a board member of the Medical Protection Society Foundation, United Kingdom.
Mulimisi Ramavhuya
(author)Mulimisi Ramavhuya qualified as a family physician with an MMed in 2009. He is currently Head of Unit, Family Medicine, in the Limpopo Department of Health and the University of Limpopo and Family Medicine module co-ordinator for MBChB 6 in Limpopo province, South Africa. He has contributed to curriculum development for Family Medicine specialist training in South Africa and co-leads the ongoing review and transformation process for the national assessment of medical specialist trainees.
Richard Cooke
(author)Richard Cooke holds qualifications in finance (Bachelor of Business Science) and medicine, having spent his initial professional years in the financial sector before transitioning wholly into the health sector. He subsequently specialised in Family Medicine, earning Fellowship of the College of Family Physicians (FCFP) and an MMed (Wits) in Family Medicine. The Department of Family Medicine and Primary Care is home to Divisions of Family Medicine, Emergency Medicine, Rural Health, Clinical Associates and Sports and Exercise Medicine, where Cooke holds overall responsibility for the respective undergraduate and postgraduate health sciences academic programmes in five districts across two provinces. Cooke chairs the Graduate Entry Medical Programme Curriculum Committee (GEMP 3&4) and is the Wits Nelson Mandela Fidel Castro Collaboration Director. He chairs the Wits Adler Museum of Medicine Advisory Board. He is a member of the SACOMD WBA National Steering Committee and the SACOMD Private Health Sciences Training Task Team. He is an examiner for the Fellowship of the College of Family Physicians of South Africa (FCFP [SA]).
Sa’ad Lahri
(author)Sa’ad Lahri is an associate professor and Head of the Division of Emergency Medicine at Stellenbosch University. He also serves as President of the College of Emergency Medicine of South Africa, guiding national standards for specialist training and assessment.
An advocate for competency-based education, Lahri has led the division’s postgraduate curriculum renewal, integrated entrustable professional activities into WBA and advised on accreditation of emergency medicine programmes in Southern Africa. Internationally, he contributes to the International Federation for Emergency Medicine Core Curriculum and Education Committee, shaping global training benchmarks.
Lahri’s scholarly interests centre on assessment validity, feedback in clinical learning environments and structured oral examinations. He supervises postgraduate research in HPE, reviews for leading journals and frequently presents at regional and international conferences.
Committed to service and mentorship, he balances clinical leadership with teaching, regularly examining for the CMSA and mentoring emerging clinicians and researchers. His work reflects a passion for improving emergency care and advancing medical education across the continent.
Tashneem Harris
(author)Tashneem Harris is an associate professor in otology, neurotology and lateral skull base surgery in the Department of Otorhinolaryngology at Groote Schuur Hospital, UCT. She is actively involved in undergraduate medical education as well as postgraduate education and training. She has mentored and supervised several postgraduate trainees for their Master’s dissertations and has also served as an examiner for the College of Otolaryngology. She has also been involved in developing Otolaryngology-specific EPAs for South Africa and serves as a UCT representative on the national steering committee for the implementation of WBA in South Africa. Additionally, she leads supervisor training workshops on work-based assessment at UCT.
Driven by a vision of equitable specialist training, Harris is advancing training in the field of otology across Africa through an African Otology Fellowship Programme, a strategic initiative designed to elevate expertise and improve patient outcomes across the continent.
Thakadu Mamashela
(author)Thakadu Mamashela is a specialist forensic pathologist with 14 years of experience as a registered forensic pathologist responsible for all administrative aspects of medico-legal death investigation services in Limpopo Province and the academic activities relating to the forensic pathology programmes (both undergraduate and postgraduate training programmes) at the University of Limpopo.
A health science educationalist of note with qualifications in health sciences education, Mamashela contributed immensely to the establishment of the 9th Medical School in South Africa as a member of the curriculum development committee that enrolled the first cohort of students in 2016, which has so far graduated five cohorts of general medical practitioners who are serving various rural communities in South Africa. He is currently the chairperson of the teaching and learning committee responsible for the curriculum review process in the school of medicine and a member of the faculty academic planning and quality assurance committee at the University of Limpopo.
He is a Fellow and a council member of the College of Forensic Pathologists in the CMSA. A member of the Medico-Legal Death Investigation International Community of Practitioners, African Academy of Forensic Sciences, the South African Association of Health Science Educationalists and National Work-based Assessment Steering Committee.
Veena S Singaram
(author)Veena S Singaram is an associate professor and the Head of the HPE Unit–University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, and holds a PhD in HPE from Maastricht University, Netherlands. She is an international fellow and faculty member of FAIMER, United States. Her contributions to the field have been recognised through many awards, including the Karolinska Institutet Prize for Research in Medical Education Fellowship from Sweden, the Distinguished Educator Award from the SAAHE and an innovation award from the School of Clinical Medicine. Singaram has supervised many Master’s and doctoral students, is widely published and is deeply committed to advancing HPE research and driving faculty development initiatives. Nationally, she contributes through her leadership on the National and Regional WBA Committees in South Africa and as co-lead of the WBA Technology Task Force.
Waseela Khan
(author)Waseela Khan is a senior lecturer and MMed programme convenor in the Division of Emergency Medicine at UCT. She holds several qualifications, including MBChB (Wits), Fellow of College of Emergency Medicine (FCEM) (SA), MMed Emergency Medicine, PGDip Health Sciences Education (Cum Laude), Master of Philosophy (MPhil) Health Science Education and completed the Education & Leadership Fellowship. She is currently a Doctor of Philosophy (DPhil) candidate in Health Science Education, exploring the implementation of programmatic assessment for emergency medicine in South Africa.
Khan is a recognised leader in emergency medicine education and curriculum transformation. She chairs the Emergency Medicine Transformation and Equity Committee and serves as Deputy Chair of the national Emergency Medicine Curriculum Working Group. Her research focuses on health science education, curriculum renewal and social accountability in medical training, with particular expertise in simulation-based medical education and decoloniality in medical curricula.
As MMed Programme Convenor, she oversees the training of 37 emergency medicine registrars across UCT and Stellenbosch University. Khan has contributed to curriculum development projects across Africa, including neonatal critical care transfers and doctoral education frameworks.
Beyond academia, she provides clinical outreach services in the Western Cape. Her commitment to transformation, equity and community engagement exemplifies her dedication to developing socially accountable health care practitioners who serve South African communities effectively.
