Chapter 3: Identity, relationship and context
- Veena S Singaram(author)
- Madeleine Muller(author)
- Sumaiya Adam(author)
- Thakadu Mamashela(author)
Export Metadata
| Title | Chapter 3: Identity, relationship and context |
|---|---|
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2026.BK586.03 |
| Landing page | http://books.aosis.co.za/index.php/ob/catalog/book/586 |
| License | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| Copyright | Tasleem Ras, Sumaiya Adam, Louis Jenkins, Lionel Green-Thompson and Vanessa Burch. Licensee: AOSIS (Pty) Ltd. The moral rights of the editors and authors have been asserted. |
| Publisher | AOSIS |
| Publication place | Durbanville, Cape Town, South Africa |
| Published on | 2026-09-30 |
| Long abstract | This chapter explores how identity, relationships and context converge to shape the educational impact of workplace-based assessment (WBA) in health professions education (HPE). Rather than treating identity as a fixed outcome, we draw on contemporary theories of professional identity formation (PIF) to frame it as a fluid, relational process, formed through participation, trust, feedback and moments of emotional connection. The relationship between supervisors and trainees is presented not as a simple hierarchy, but as a dynamic space where identity is continuously negotiated. Power dynamics, psychological safety and the often-unspoken messages of the hidden curriculum all influence how this relationship unfolds. Beyond these interpersonal encounters, we locate WBA within the everyday realities of clinical teams, where communication, trust and shared responsibility are as crucial as technical skill. Using the lens of social capital, we explore how practices such as feedback and observation are influenced by institutional culture and peer networks. When WBA is aligned with a culture of openness and support, it can strengthen collective competence, particularly in environments stretched by limited resources. Recognising the unique contextual realities of the South African health care system, the chapter foregrounds issues of linguistic diversity, historical inequities and systemic resource challenges. These contextual factors influence not only the feasibility of implementing WBA but also the inclusivity and legitimacy of identity formation processes. Ultimately, we argue that WBA must be reimagined as a socially situated and ethically grounded practice. It should contribute not only to the assessment of competence but also to the cultivation of professional identity and the development of safe, inclusive clinical training environments. |
| Print length | 23 pages |
| Language | English (Original) |
| THEMA |
|
| BIC |
|
| Keywords |
|
Contributors
Veena S Singaram
(author)Veena S Singaram is an associate professor and the Head of the HPE Unit–University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, and holds a PhD in HPE from Maastricht University, Netherlands. She is an international fellow and faculty member of FAIMER, United States. Her contributions to the field have been recognised through many awards, including the Karolinska Institutet Prize for Research in Medical Education Fellowship from Sweden, the Distinguished Educator Award from the SAAHE and an innovation award from the School of Clinical Medicine. Singaram has supervised many Master’s and doctoral students, is widely published and is deeply committed to advancing HPE research and driving faculty development initiatives. Nationally, she contributes through her leadership on the National and Regional WBA Committees in South Africa and as co-lead of the WBA Technology Task Force.
Madeleine Muller
(author)Madeleine Muller is a family physician at Cecilia Makiwane Hospital in Mdantsane, South Africa, and a senior lecturer at Walter Sisulu University, South Africa. She provides clinical services and teaches and mentors medical students, registrars and medical officers. Muller graduated with a Master’s in Health Professional Education from Stellenbosch University in March 2025 and is enrolled to begin her PhD in 2027.
Muller is convenor for the CMSA Diploma in HIV Management, and she serves on the CMSA Senate. Muller is part of the National CMSA/SACOMD committee responsible for implementing WBAs in postgraduate medical education and is one of the facilitators rolling out the Supervisor Workplace Assessment and Teaching Training for clinical supervisors across the 10 South African medical universities.
Muller is on the steering committee for the South African Association of Health Educationalists Eastern Cape Chapter and is an executive committee member of the Rural Doctors Association of Southern Africa, where she oversees the mentoring portfolio and manages the Rural Onboarding programme. She serves on the executive board of the Professional Association of Transgender Health in South Africa.
Sumaiya Adam
(author)Sumaiya Adam is a clinician-scientist and professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at the University of Pretoria, South Africa, where she specialises in Maternal–Foetal Medicine. She has been actively involved in both undergraduate and postgraduate training and curriculum development, with particular focus on EPAs and WBA. Her work includes participation in national task teams, academic committees and professional bodies, contributing to efforts to strengthen clinical training and assessment in South Africa.
In addition to her educational contributions, she leads a diabetes-in-pregnancy clinic and engages in research on maternal health and non-communicable diseases. She collaborates with local and international colleagues and contributes to networks such as International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics and World Health Organization (WHO) working groups. As a supervisor and mentor of postgraduate students, she values shared learning and collective scholarship and remains committed to advancing both clinical care and medical education in her field.
Thakadu Mamashela
(author)Thakadu Mamashela is a specialist forensic pathologist with 14 years of experience as a registered forensic pathologist responsible for all administrative aspects of medico-legal death investigation services in Limpopo Province and the academic activities relating to the forensic pathology programmes (both undergraduate and postgraduate training programmes) at the University of Limpopo.
A health science educationalist of note with qualifications in health sciences education, Mamashela contributed immensely to the establishment of the 9th Medical School in South Africa as a member of the curriculum development committee that enrolled the first cohort of students in 2016, which has so far graduated five cohorts of general medical practitioners who are serving various rural communities in South Africa. He is currently the chairperson of the teaching and learning committee responsible for the curriculum review process in the school of medicine and a member of the faculty academic planning and quality assurance committee at the University of Limpopo.
He is a Fellow and a council member of the College of Forensic Pathologists in the CMSA. A member of the Medico-Legal Death Investigation International Community of Practitioners, African Academy of Forensic Sciences, the South African Association of Health Science Educationalists and National Work-based Assessment Steering Committee.
