Skip to main content
punctum books

Condensed Meanings: Redaction Dialogues on Ethnography in Occupied Tibet

  • Charlene Makley (author)
  • Dondrup Donyol (author)
Chapter of: Redacted: Writing in the Negative Space of the State(pp. 97–119)

Export Metadata

  • ONIX 3.1
    Cannot generate record: No publications supplied
  • ONIX 3.0
    • Thoth
      Cannot generate record: No publications supplied
    • Project MUSE
      Cannot generate record: No BIC or BISAC subject code
    • OAPEN
      Cannot generate record: Missing PDF URL
    • JSTOR
      Cannot generate record: No BISAC subject code
    • Google Books
      Cannot generate record: No BIC, BISAC or LCC subject code
    • OverDrive
      Cannot generate record: No priced EPUB or PDF URL
  • ONIX 2.1
    • EBSCO Host
      Cannot generate record: No PDF or EPUB URL
    • ProQuest Ebrary
      Cannot generate record: No PDF or EPUB URL
  • CSV
  • JSON
  • OCLC KBART
  • BibTeX
  • CrossRef DOI deposit
    Cannot generate record: This work does not have any ISBNs
  • MARC 21 Record
    Cannot generate record: MARC records are not available for chapters
  • MARC 21 Markup
    Cannot generate record: MARC records are not available for chapters
  • MARC 21 XML
    Cannot generate record: MARC records are not available for chapters
Metadata
TitleCondensed Meanings
SubtitleRedaction Dialogues on Ethnography in Occupied Tibet
ContributorCharlene Makley (author)
Dondrup Donyol (author)
DOIhttps://doi.org/10.53288/0466.1.07
Landing pagehttps://punctumbooks.com/titles/redacted-writing-in-the-negative-space-of-the-state/
Licensehttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Publisherpunctum books
Published on2024-10-27
Long abstractIn this piece composed of short stories and erasure poems written in dialogue with each other, we reflect on the (im)possibilities of ethnography amidst state-led erasure and threat in China's Tibet before and after 2008, when Tibetans began to openly protest both their political economic marginalization and heightened assimilation pressures in the wake of the "Great Develop the West" campaign (2000-) and the rise of president Xi Jinping's more authoritarian policies (2013-). The ongoing militarization of Tibetan regions and increasing pressures on local officials to "maintain stability" (Ch. weiwen) and promote Chinese-style "civilization" (Ch. wenming), have meant that the threat of socioeconomic ostracization, detention, and torture is now much more present and pervasive for Tibetan citizens. We draw on Makley's twenty-seven years of ethnographic research conducted as a white American anthropologist in Tibetan regions, and on Dondrup Donyol's experiences conducting ethnographic research as a native anthropologist there. We strove for an emergent and dialogic writing process by sharing and responding to each others' narratives. As a way to illustrate sites of erasure imposed by authoritarian rule, we deploy oppositional forms of redaction in unexpected ways (not just names, places and other identifying markers of persons), in order to intervene in locally influential Chinese-language state texts. This process, our history of close collaborations, and our very different positions as ethnographers of Tibet, yielded new insights and avenues for us in rethinking the nature and roles of ethnography under authoritarian erasure.
Page rangepp. 97–119
Print length23 pages
LanguageEnglish (Original)
Keywords
  • Tibet
  • China
  • erasure poem
  • state violence
  • land
Contributors

Charlene Makley

(author)
Professor of Anthropology at Reed College

Charlene Makley is Professor of Anthropology at Reed College in Portland, Oregon. Her work has explored the history and cultural politics of █████-building, █████-led development and Buddhist revival among Tibetans in China's ███████ ████████ ████ since 1992. Her second book, The Battle for Fortune: █████-Led Development, Personhood and █████ among Tibetans in China, published in 2018 by Cornell University Press and the Weatherhead East Asia Institute at Columbia University, is an ethnography of state-local relations in the historically ███████ region of ███████(██ ███████ ████████) in the wake of China's Great Open the West campaign and during the  ████████  █████████ on ███████ ██████.

Dondrup Donyol

(author)

Dondrup Donyol is a researcher and his scholarship is partly a product of self-censorship. His research explores █████ the politics of fear █████ hope █████ creativity.